It’s that time of year again, spring is in the air (mostly!) and thoughts turn to summer holidays relaxing on the beach, swimming in the sea, snorkelling over colourful corals and silvery fishes. But what is the future for these seemingly idyllic ecosystems? Current research suggests that coral reef ecosystems globally are under mounting pressure, from warming seas, acidification, over fishing, tourist damage etc., however until this week I was unaware of the potentially wide ranging impacts of the tropical fish trade. As someone who has kept fish as pets and occasionally visits aquariums, I wanted to know more about how fish are sourced for aquaria displays.
A recent article from National Geographic states that up to 98% of marine ornamental fish cannot be bred in captivity on a commercial scale; therefore they must be collected from the wild, namely from Southeast Asia. According to a report from NOAA in 2008, up to 90% of the 11 million marine aquarium fish imported to the USA are caught illegally using cyanide. Although fishing using cyanide has been banned across the Philippines, Sri Lanka and Indonesia, there is little enforcement and with huge sums at stake, more and more fishermen are turning from fishing for food to supplying the aquarium trade (worth up to $200 million p.a. according to the WWF).
When cyanide tablets are ground down, they can be mixed with water and using squeezy bottles, used to flush out stunned fish from hiding places in the reef. Cyanide impairs movement and breathing in fish and with such an imprecise method of delivery, many simply die. It has been estimated that for each fish collected, a square yard of coral is killed or bleached (which of course has further knock on impacts across the reef ecosystem). It appears that both the fishermen and middle men involved in this trade are very quick to pass on their catch, as there is a high risk of fish death, even some time after collection and then of course the risk is passed onto the unsuspecting aquarium owners who will need to replace their collection if a fish dies. But what can be done to break this cycle and ensure that fish are ethically supplied from sustainable sources?
New laws are currently being drafted globally, with new legislation being debated and huge petitions aiming to make cyanide testing and certification of imported fish mandatory. However, this does not reduce pressures on tropical fishes still being collected from the wild in huge numbers, and many are now calling for only captive bred fish to be sold and traded. It is perhaps ironic that after the release of Disney’s film Finding Nemo (in which a wild fish is taken off the reef for a private aquarium and the tank fish fight for freedom in the open ocean), demand for clownfish and tangs shot up by 40% almost overnight.
Although many clownfish species can be bred in captivity, royal tangs are now being over collected and are endangered in the wild. A new app called Tank Watch (developed by the Humane Society of the United States) aims to help people trace reef-friendly species and public awareness campaigns are aiming to educate people (like me) by highlighting the potential back story of each aquarium fish.
Of course on the flip side, the aquarium trade has benefitted some rare species, such as the red-tailed black shark which is critically endangered and possibly extinct in the wild, but thanks to the the interest generated by aquarists, dedicated breeding programs have been set up and a steady captive population now can help preserve this species.
It’s a contentious issue, with opinions running strongly on both sides, including the “Hands off my hobby” campaign of the Ornamental Aquatic Association who aim to protect the “pleasure [gained from fish keeping] as well as [the] social, economic and
health benefits” of the fish trade to the UK. On the opposing side, marine campaign groups such as Sea Shepherd have launched their “Operation Reef Defence” to end the wild caught marine fish trade.
Public support is now building for a European wide investigation into the exotic pet trade, and perhaps the end goal should be to ensure ethical standards and protection of reef ecosystems are upheld so that at the end of the day, everyone can sit back and enjoy the fish.
If you fancy more fishy facts (or if you have found a sunfish washed up) please contact me using the comments section below or follow me on Twitter or Instagram @SunfishResearch 🙂